Can I Question God and Still Have Faith?
Share
Maybe the questions aren't the problem. Maybe we need to get better at asking them.
There are questions Christians sometimes feel like we're not supposed to ask.
Why didn't God answer my prayer? Why am I still waiting? Why did I believe God told me something—and then it didn't happen? Why would God allow this? Why does Scripture seem clear to one person and complicated to another? What if I'm angry? What if I'm disappointed? What if I have doubts?
And perhaps the question underneath all of them is:
Can I ask these things and still be a woman of faith?
I believe the answer is yes.
In fact, some of the deepest faith I have developed began when I stopped pretending I didn't have questions.
Faith Isn't the Absence of Questions
Somewhere along the way, many of us learned to associate strong faith with certainty.
Believe. Trust. Don't doubt. Have more faith. Pray harder.
Those words can be beautiful when they point us toward God, but they can become painful when they are used to shut down honest questions.
Scripture does not give us a picture of people who never questioned God. David asked why God seemed far away. Habakkuk asked how long he would have to cry out before God answered. Job wrestled openly with suffering he could not understand. Jeremiah lamented. The disciples misunderstood Jesus repeatedly.
And one desperate father said:
“I do believe; help my unbelief!”
— Mark 9:24 NASB
Jesus did not reject him for saying it.
His faith and his struggle existed in the same sentence.
Maybe ours can too.
What If God Didn't Answer the Way You Expected?
It is one thing to trust God before you know the outcome. It is another to pray, believe, wait—and watch something happen that looks nothing like what you asked for.
Maybe the marriage was not restored. Maybe the relationship ended. Maybe the healing did not come. Maybe the door stayed closed. Maybe you waited years for something you were certain God would do.
Christians sometimes rush into those moments with explanations: Everything happens for a reason. God's timing is perfect. You just have to trust Him.
Sometimes those words are true. And sometimes they arrive before we have even had permission to grieve.
The Bible gives us another language for those moments:
Lament.
Lament does not pretend everything is okay. It brings the pain directly to God.
David begins Psalm 13 with:
“How long, LORD? Will You forget me forever?”
— Psalm 13:1 NASB
And only a few verses later:
“But I have trusted in Your faithfulness; My heart shall rejoice in Your salvation.”
— Psalm 13:5 NASB
Both statements live in the same prayer.
God, I don't understand.
And:
God, I still trust You.
That is faith too.
What If I Thought God Spoke—and I Was Wrong?
This is one of the harder conversations we do not have enough.
Christians often say: God told me. God put this on my heart. I felt led. I had peace about it.
But what happens when we believe we heard God and later realize we may have misunderstood?
I have learned something important:
Being wrong about what I thought God said does not necessarily mean God stopped speaking. It may mean I am still learning to listen.
We are human. We bring our desires, fears, wounds, expectations, experiences, and assumptions into discernment.
Scripture repeatedly tells us to test, examine, seek wisdom, and grow in discernment. That suggests discernment is something we learn.
Maturity is not necessarily becoming someone who never gets it wrong. Sometimes maturity is becoming humble enough to say:
I believed this was God. I may have been wrong. What can I learn from this?
God is not threatened by that sentence.
What If I'm Angry With God?
Tell Him.
He already knows.
The Psalms contain grief, confusion, anger, fear, disappointment, and raw questions directed toward God. Biblical faith is surprisingly honest.
What would happen if, instead of giving God the prayer we think we are supposed to pray, we gave Him the one actually inside us?
God, I'm angry. I don't understand. I thought You were going to do something different. I'm disappointed. I'm afraid. I still want You, but right now I don't understand You.
That is not necessarily rebellion.
Sometimes it is relationship.
Because intimacy requires honesty.
Better Questions Can Lead to Deeper Faith
This is part of what I want to do differently here. I do not want to give women another collection of easy Christian answers. I want us to ask better questions.
What if waiting on God sometimes requires action? What if having faith does not mean denying what is happening? What if hearing God also requires enough humility to admit when we may have heard Him wrong? What if grief and faith can exist together? What if questioning something we have been taught is not automatically the same as questioning God?
And what if the God we discover on the other side of our questions is more loving, patient, present, and trustworthy than we understood Him to be before?
Jesus is not threatened by our questions.
I do not believe we need to be either.
Bring Your Questions
If your faith feels complicated right now, you do not have to clean it up before coming to God.
Bring the disappointment. Bring the doubt. Bring the anger. Bring the confusion. Bring the question you have been afraid to say out loud.
And bring whatever faith you have—even if today it sounds like:
“I do believe; help my unbelief!”
— Mark 9:24 NASB
You do not need perfect certainty to keep walking with God.
Sometimes faith simply looks like continuing to turn toward Him while you are still waiting for answers.
And perhaps some questions will not weaken your faith at all.
Perhaps they'll lead you deeper into it.
You Are Worthy. You Have Purpose. You Are Loved.
If conversations like this are what you've been looking for, stay connected. We'll keep talking about faith, waiting, hearing God, unanswered prayer, healing, relationships, sexuality, motherhood, divorce—and some of the questions we do not always know how to ask in church.